Greece is famous as the cradle of
democracy, but we should all remember that, during the golden age of classical
Greek democracy, the system was more or less restricted to Athens, and moreover
was seen by the other Greek city-states (generally ruled by old-fashioned
monarchies or oligarchies) as a bizarre fringe movement that dangerously placed
untrained civilians in positions that really ought to be occupied by
experienced professionals. It was a direct democracy, which meant that it did
involve putting randomly-chosen inexperienced laypeople in decision-making
positions, which certainly invites certain difficulties, although their lack of
experience and connections was supposed to be a benefit (a safeguard against
cronyism). We should also remember that Athenian democracy was effectively crushed
when Philip of Macedon conquered all the Greek city-states (followed by some
Hellenistic tyrants until all of Greece was absorbed into the Roman empire) so
the heyday of Athenian democracy really wasn’t very long--only a few centuries.
Still, Athenian democracy had its selling
points. It was an experimental system in the Greek world, certainly innovative
against a backdrop of oligarchies and monarchies. And there was definitely no
precedent for democracy in myth, no illustration of the gods buying into
Athenian political procedures. If you want to hear about the government of the
gods, go check Hesiod’s Theogony. It’s
just pages and pages of one dynast overthrowing another. Ouranos seizes power
as soon as there’s a population of gods to hold power over. Ouranos’ son Cronos
overthrows Ouranos. Cronos tries to eat his children to prevent himself from
being likewise overthrown, but Zeus is hidden away and overthrows Cronos (via
castration). Zeus holds autocratic power and prevents any of his children from
becoming powerful enough to overthrow him. It is a despotic monarchy, and Zeus
has his lightning bolts to destroy anyone who challenges his authority.
The US is not a despotic monarchy, and in
fact on Tuesday we have the opportunity to go out and vote for who we want to
be in charge of certain powers and decisions. If you live in the US, I would
strongly encourage you to read up on the elections under contention and
candidates available in your area, and vote. Historically, not many people have
had the opportunity to choose who rules over them, so I encourage you to take
advantage of this anomaly.
No comments:
Post a Comment